How Newspaper Horoscopes Work (and Why They Miss)
The sun-sign column is a British invention from 1930. Here is how it is written, why it can only be general and how to get more from it.
Newspaper horoscopes work by treating your star sign as the starting point of a simplified chart, then describing where the planets currently fall for everyone born under that sign. Because each of the twelve forecasts has to fit millions of readers at once, a sun-sign column can only ever be general.
Where did the newspaper horoscope come from?
The story starts with a royal baby. Princess Margaret was born on 21 August 1930, and John Gordon, editor of the Sunday Express, wanted a horoscope for her. His first choice, the celebrity palmist and astrologer Cheiro, was not available, so the job went to Cheiro’s assistant, R. H. Naylor.
Naylor’s article, “What the Stars Foretell for the New Princess”, appeared on 24 August 1930. It forecast an eventful life for her and, according to later accounts of the article, important events for the royal family around her seventh year. Her uncle Edward VIII abdicated in 1936, when she was six, which did Naylor’s reputation no harm in hindsight.
Readers wrote in asking for more, and the paper printed further forecasts. In early October 1930 one of them warned that British aircraft would be in danger. On 5 October the airship R101 crashed in France. The forecast had named dates a few days later, so it was a near miss at best, but the paper hailed it as a success. From 12 October 1930 Naylor had a weekly column, the first regular astrology column in a British newspaper.
Those early columns were not arranged by star sign. Naylor wrote forecasts by birthday, alongside predictions about world affairs. Research into the original newspapers shows a rival, Edward Lyndoe, starting in The People on 1 October 1933, and the twelve-sign layout taking shape during the mid-1930s. By 1940 astrology columns were running in every mass-circulation Sunday paper.
The same record shows the misses. In the summer of 1939 Naylor repeatedly told readers there would be no war. Hit-and-miss was part of the form from the start.
How do columnists write for twelve signs at once?
A full birth chart needs a date, time and place. A columnist has only your star sign, so most use a method called solar houses. Houses are the twelve sections of a chart that stand for areas of life, such as money, home and work, and our guide to the 12 houses of the birth chart covers them in full.
With solar houses, the columnist places your star sign in the first house. The next sign becomes the second house, and so on round the wheel. Then they look at where the planets are in the sky this week and note which house each one lands in for each sign.
Suppose Venus, the planet linked with affection and enjoyment, is moving through Libra. Here is how that single fact turns into different forecasts.
| Star sign | Libra is its solar house | So the column talks about |
|---|---|---|
| Aries | 7th | Partnerships and close relationships |
| Cancer | 4th | Home and family |
| Leo | 3rd | Conversations, siblings and short trips |
| Capricorn | 10th | Career and reputation |
| Libra | 1st | Your own confidence and appearance |
The columnist repeats this for the Sun, the new and full moons and the other planets, picks the two or three strongest themes for each sign and writes them up in a few sentences. Daily columns lean heavily on the Moon, because it changes sign every two to three days and is the only thing moving fast enough to make Tuesday different from Wednesday.
So the method is a real one, borrowed from fuller chart work. Columnists vary in how carefully they apply it, and in how they choose to word what they find.
Why can a column only be general?
- One forecast, millions of readers. Each star sign covers roughly one person in twelve. Whatever is written for Scorpio has to be read by every Scorpio in the country, from a teenager in Leeds to a retired couple in Cardiff.
- It uses one piece of your chart. Your Sun sign is important, but a column cannot see your Moon sign, your rising sign or where the planets were when you were born.
- Space is tight. A few dozen words cannot carry much detail, so the wording has to stay broad.
- Broad wording invites hits and misses. A line about “a conversation that clears the air” will fit some readers that day and pass others by. We tend to remember the days it fitted.
None of this makes a column worthless. It makes it a general weather forecast for a very large region, not a report on your street.
Why should you read your rising sign as well?
Solar houses are a stand-in. In a full chart, the houses are counted from the rising sign, or ascendant, the sign that was on the eastern horizon when you were born. That is why many columnists suggest reading the forecast for your rising sign as well as your star sign.
Read this way, the entry for your rising sign often describes the areas of life that are active, because it matches your real houses more closely. The entry for your star sign speaks more to your mood and sense of purpose. To find your rising sign you need a reasonably accurate time of birth, and our guide on how to find your birth time in the UK explains where to look.
In the Vedic tradition, forecasts are usually read from the Moon sign, called the rashi, rather than the Sun sign. If you follow Indian horoscopes, our guide to the Vedic Moon sign explains how to find yours.
How does a personal chart differ from a column?
| Newspaper column | Personal birth chart | |
|---|---|---|
| Based on | Star sign only | Date, exact time and place of birth |
| Shared by | Everyone born under that sign | Almost nobody else |
| Houses | Counted from the Sun sign | Counted from the rising sign |
| Planets | Where they are in the sky now | Where they were at birth, compared with now |
| Detail | A few sentences | As much as you want to explore |
A personal chart is still a tool for reflection, not a promise about the future. What it adds is focus. Instead of a line meant for a twelfth of the population, you get a picture drawn from your own Sun, Moon and rising sign and the planets around them.
Frequently asked questions
Who invented newspaper horoscopes?
The British astrologer R. H. Naylor is usually credited. He wrote a horoscope for the newborn Princess Margaret in the Sunday Express on 24 August 1930, and reader interest led to a weekly column from October 1930. The twelve star sign format developed in British papers during the 1930s.
Are newspaper horoscopes accurate?
They can only be general. Each forecast is written for everyone born under one star sign, which is roughly a twelfth of the population, and it uses the Sun sign alone. Some days it will chime with your life and some days it will not. Treat it as light reflection.
Should I read my sun sign or rising sign horoscope?
Read both if you know your rising sign. Columns are written using houses counted from the sign, and in a full chart the houses start from the rising sign, so that entry often fits daily events better. Your star sign entry speaks more to mood and purpose.
Why do horoscopes in different papers say different things?
Columnists start from the same planetary positions but make different choices. Each picks which planets to emphasise, how to interpret them and how to phrase the result in a few sentences. With a dozen possible themes and space for two or three, two honest columnists can easily differ.
The takeaway
Newspaper horoscopes are a British invention from 1930, written by placing your star sign at the start of a simplified chart. That makes them broad by design. Read them for general themes, try your rising sign too, and look to a full birth chart when you want something personal.
Newsletter
Astrology insights in your inbox
New articles and seasonal guidance, sent occasionally. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
